So your Magistrate’s Decision came out in your Ohio Family Law case and you do not like the result. Here are 17 things you need to know about Objections to Magistrate’s Decisions in Ohio.
- Objections to Magistrate’s Decisions are governed by Ohio Rule of Civil Procedure 53(D)(3).
- Sometimes the Judge’s Entry Adopting the Magistrate’s Decision comes in the mail at the same time as the Decision. That does not mean that you cannot object to the Magistrate’s Decision.
- Per Ohio Rule of Civil Procedure 53(D)(3)(a)(ii), a Magistrate’s Decision may be general unless Findings of Fact are timely requested. Timely requested means that Findings of Fact are requested before the entry of the Magistrate’s Decision or within 7 days after the entry of the Magistrate’s Decision.
- It is going to be difficult to Object to the Magistrate’s Decision without Findings of Fact.
- If a party timely makes a request for Findings of Fact and Conclusions of law, the time for filing objections begins to run when the Magistrate files a decision that includes findings of fact and conclusions of law. Civ. R. (D)(3)(b)(i)
- A party may file written objections to the Magistrate’s Decision within 14 days of the filing of the decision. Civ. R. (D)(3)(b)(i)
- For good cause shown, courts shall allow a reasonable extension of time for a party to file a motion to set aside a Magistrate’s order or objections to a Magistrate’s decision. Civil Rule 53(D)(5) says that failure of the clerk to timely serve a party is good cause. Note, this does not apply to a request for findings of fact and conclusions of law.
- Objections must be specific and state all grounds for objection.
- If any party files objections, the other party may file a response no more than 10 days after the filing of the objections. Civ. R. (D)(3)(b)(i)
- Objections to a factual finding must be supported by a transcript or an affidavit of that evidence if a transcript is not available. These transcripts must be filed within 30 days of the filing of the objections unless the court extends the time for filing in writing. Civ. R. 53(D)(3)(b)(iii).
- Trial transcripts are expensive, and the court is generally not going to pay for the transcript, the cost goes to the objecting party. Most of the time the court reporter will give you an estimate of the cost in advance if you ask.
- Except for a claim of plain error, a party may not appeal the court’s adoption of any factual finding or legal conclusion not specifically designated as a finding of fact or conclusion of law unless the party has objected to that finding or conclusion of law at the trial court level.
- Per Ohio Rule of Civil Procedure 53(D)(4)(a), a magistrate’s decision is not effective unless adopted by the court.
- The Judge is to take an independent review as to the objected matters to ascertain that the magistrate has properly determined the factual matters and appropriately applied the law. Civ. R. 53(D)(4)(d). This does NOT mean that the Judge gives you a new trial.
- The Judge MAY hear additional evidence on objections to appeal, but may refuse to do so unless the objecting party demonstrates that the could not have, with reasonable diligence, produced that evidence for consideration by the Magistrate. Civ. R. 53(D)(4)(d).
- If the court enters a Judgment pursuant to Civ. R. (D(3)(b)(i) within the 14 day time period allowed for objections, the timely filing of objections to the Magistrate’s decision operates as a stay of execution of the Judgment until the court disposes of the objections. Civ. R. 53(D)(4)(e)(i)
- The Judge may enter an interim order on the basis of a Magistrate’s decision without waiting for a ruling on timely objections where immediate relief is warranted . Civ. R. 53(D(4)(e)(ii). The order can last not more than 28 days, but can be extended in increments.
Columbus Ohio Family Lawyer
CALL NOW at (614) 225-9316
DISCLAIMER – Read it, it’s important!